Writer Problem #462 — Does the ending work?

So I finally finished one of my WIPs (insert wild cheering here). I’m stuck on a title, but that’s normal for me.

What isn’t normal is that I’m unsure about the ending.

See, I wrote the story and ended it at one point, but I had a nagging feeling that there was a bit more to tell. So I wrote another ending and wonder if it’s really needed.

My beta reader says he likes the new ending, but I’m wondering what others might think.